Dunfermline Athletic

News and Events | The Cottage Hospital Challenge Cup

The Dunfermline Cottage Hospital Cup was introduced in season 1896/97, specifically to raise funds for the recently established Cottage Hospital.

The Cottage Hospital Challenge Cup is on display in the Local History Dept, Dunfermline Carnegie Library and Galleries until 29th May 2026

In the later years of the nineteenth century, charity competitions were established by football clubs to support local good causes. The most famously known in Scotland was the Glasgow Charity Cup, which ran from 1877 to 1966, while in England the Charity Shield (now known as the Community Shield), still provides the season opener to English football in a match between the Premier League winners and the FA Cup winners.

Fife was no different and a number of football competitions were established, the first of which was the Dunfermline Charity Cup which was inaugurated in season 1887/88, and played for three times before the competition was renamed the Fife Charity Cup. It remained until 1927 by which time these competitions ceased and clubs found other ways to support charitable causes.

The Dunfermline Cottage Hospital Cup was introduced in season 1896/97, specifically to raise funds for the recently established Cottage Hospital. It had been opened in 1894 for the treatment of non-infectious and surgical cases and had a full-time staff of three. It had room for sixteen patients who were looked after by the general practitioners of Dunfermline who gave their services free of charge.

A charitable institution, the bequests and donations it received meant that by 1905 it had outgrown the status of `˜cottage` hospital and became instead the Dunfermline and West Fife Hospital. As football clubs in the area supplied the hospital with a regular stream of patients, it was only fair that they should also contribute to the hospital`s upkeep and for several years an end-of-season tournament was played at East End to raise money.

In its inaugural season, Dunfermline defeated Lochgelly United 3-0 in the semi-final before winning the final 2-1 against Cowdenbeath in front of a big crowd at East End Park on 12 May 1897. In its second season, the contest became a Junior football competition, with Dunfermline Athletic at that point running a Junior football team. After defeating Kingseat Athletic 2-0 in the semi-final, the Dunfermline Athletic Juniors won the Cup with a 7-2 win over Hearts of Beath.

The tournament may have been established for charitable causes, but no quarter was given on the football park. The semi-final against Kingseat ended with a punch-up and three players being sent off, while in the final, Hearts of Beath walked off the park after a disputed penalty was awarded against them.

Despite all games in the competition being played at East End Park, Cowdenbeath were to be the winners in both season 1898/99 and 1899/1900. In both cases, the final was played over two legs with Lochgelly United providing the opposition on both occasions. In season 1900/1901, and despite Dunfermline Athletic being in considerable disarray as a club, it went on to win the Cottage Hospital Cup for a third time, defeating Hearts of Beath 2-0 at East End Park on 18 May 1901.

The status and organisation of the Cup once again reverted to a competition under Junior football rules in season 1901/02, with Lochgelly Rangers emerging as winners. By season 1902/03, the competition had moved its base to North End Park, Cowdenbeath. Dunfermline Athletic were defeated by Cowdenbeath in the semi-final but they in turn were beaten 3-2 by Lochgelly United in the final.

The competition ran for one final time in season 1903/04. Having beaten Hearts of Beath 4-0 in the semi-final, Dunfermline Athletic were due to meet Lochgelly United in the final at East End Park on Friday 27 May 1904. However, earlier in the day Lochgelly requested that the game be postponed until the following Tuesday and the venue switched to Cowdenbeath. As this was after the cut-off date imposed by the Scottish FA, the local newspaper reported that `it is expected that the trophy will be awarded to the Athletic`.


Duncan Simpson
Dunfermline Athletic Club Historian
May 2026



Related Stories


views: 87

To top